tyllr

How to have difficult conversations - virtually

Hannah Keal

To start with the obvious - difficult conversations are, well, blooming difficult.

Whether you’re delivering some hard-to-hear feedback, having a 1:1 with a team member who is newly bereaved or letting someone know they won’t be offered that promotion they’ve been gunning for - the sweaty palms are real.

section image

What’s different about having difficult conversations virtually?


On the face of it, having difficult conversations virtually can seem a bit easier than tackling them face-to-face. There is a sense of detachment that comes from being behind your screen. You’re in your own environment - and once it’s done, you can simply exit the zoom room and breathe a sigh of relief.

However - it’s important to recognise what is lost when we conduct these meaningful interactions virtually. Crucially, we have less access to the non-verbal cues that help us read people’s reactions and assess how our message is being received. These cues - gestures, body language, posture, eye contact - are a huge part of how we communicate. In fact, some research suggests as little as 7% of communication is verbal.

How can we set ourselves up for success?

However challenging it might be, in today’s world where a lot of us work in hybrid and remote-first settings, we need to be able to have all different types of conversations virtually - including the tough ones.

The first thing to bear in mind when tackling a tough conversation virtually is what happens before you’ve even sent the meeting invite. Set aside time to prepare and start by getting curious about the situation at hand. Pull together a short agenda with questions to ask your team member, so you can get their perspective on the situation and build towards a way forward together. Difficult conversations shouldn’t ever feel like a ‘drop and run’. To be effective, they need to be a two way street. Asking open-ended questions gives a sense that it is you and your team member against the difficult situation - which can help demonstrate care and lead to a better resolution.

Once you have planned your agenda it’s important to give your team member a heads up about the type of conversation you want to have prior to the meeting. This will avoid any feeling that they are being blindsided.


A note on the neuroscience of tough conversations

Difficult conversations are challenging because of how our brains are wired. Humans have evolved to be acutely sensitive to threat. Historically, this was very useful for avoiding things that posed a very real physical risk to our safety. Fast forward to today: we encounter far fewer sabre tooth tigers - but unfortunately our brain is unable to stop this ‘fight, flight or freeze’ response being triggered by perceived threats to our emotional safety.

When this happens, our hippocampus - the part of the brain that is predominantly responsible for creating new memories - simply shuts down. So, however carefully you’ve crafted your conversation pointers, if you trigger this threat response, your direct report is unlikely to be able to process, reflect upon or act on much of what you’re saying.

All that is to say - preparation and priming ahead of the conversation is key. Even more so when you’re scheduling a virtual meeting given these tend to be slightly more transactional due to our understandable preference for minimising screen time (which is also very tiring for our brains!)

...The way to create true buy-in is to help individuals connect allyship to their personal values: helping them see how engaging in active allyship is a part of the person that they want to be.”

Quickfire tips for the conversation itself

Having a plan of action goes a long way to setting both you and your team member up for a valuable conversation. Here are some other things to consider before you sit down for that important chat.

There’s no harm in addressing the elephant in the room and calling out that this will be a challenging or uncomfortable conversation. You might want to express a wish that you could be there in person.

Focus on staying present rather than sticking super rigidly to a script. Without body language cues, it's important to dial up the other elements of active listening. This includes things like taking time to paraphrase to ensure you’ve understood the perspective your teammate is sharing and avoiding judgemental language.

Agree on a follow up plan. Ensure you take notes and document what you’ve agreed with your team member - then revisit these next steps in your next 1:1.

So there you have it - plenty of tools to make difficult virtual conversations that little bit easier.


A final reminder

Difficult conversations can be emotionally draining, especially when you’re not surrounded by colleagues who can help you shake off some of that nervous tension afterwards. Make sure you leave some buffer time in your diary after a tough conversation to give yourself the space to self-regulate and reflect on how it’s gone.

More like this

Join the list

Our community newsletter sparks curiosity about the world around you and challenge your thinking. Sound good?